Specialty Digest

Global English editionLearners’ Study Dashboard — in development
The Knowledge Library for All

Conscience Charges More for Bigger Theft

Share
Link copied
Justice, honesty and integrity · Saturday

A lost wallet with more money in it is returned more often; conscience charges more for a bigger theft.

The Daily Mirror: A Specialty Digest Publication

Conscience charges more for bigger theft: in a 40-country experiment, lost wallets holding more money were reported more often, not less. Most people would rather stay honest than see themselves as thieves.

The mirror

A wallet lies on a bus seat and the whole row goes quiet. Every passenger can see it, and each is quietly working out what keeping it would cost: the cash, and the voice that follows you home. We assume that voice loses when the sum is big. In practice it often raises its price.

Conscience charges more for bigger theft: lost wallets with more money were reported more often In a 2019 Science study of 17,303 lost wallets in 355 cities and 40 countries, the share reported rose from 46 per cent with no money to 72 per cent with about 94 US dollars, pooled across the United States, the United Kingdom and Poland. Specialty Digest The Daily Mirror A lost wallet with more money in it is returned more often; conscience charges more for a bigger theft. Wallet with no money 46% were reported add about $94 Wallet with about $94 72% were reported 17,303 wallets, 355 cities, 40 countries, Science 2019 72% of the $94 wallets were reported The Daily Mirror · Specialty Digest
The bigger the temptation, the louder the conscience. Source: Cohn et al., Science, 2019 (pooled: United States, United Kingdom, Poland).

The fact behind it

Verified fact

In a 2019 study in Science, researchers from the Universities of Michigan, Zurich and Utah handed in 17,303 apparently lost wallets at banks, hotels, post offices, museums and police stations in 355 cities across 40 countries. In 38 of the 40 countries, wallets with money were reported more often than empty ones. Where a larger sum was tested (the United States, the United Kingdom and Poland), the share reported rose from 46 per cent with no money to 61 per cent with about US$13 and 72 per cent with about US$94.

Honesty was far from universal: average return rates ranged from 14 to 76 per cent between countries, and the wallets were handed to staff at institutions, not found on a street. The authors explain the pattern by finders not wanting to see themselves as thieves, plus concern for the owner. Read more on why integrity matters on International Anti-Corruption Day, on acting on the inner voice and on how trust is built on a team.

The pause

What would my conscience charge me today if nobody were watching?

Apply it today

Return one small thing you could easily keep: extra change, a borrowed pen, an item a shop forgot to charge for.

The Daily Mirror: A Specialty Digest Publication.

Share this Mirror

Someone you know may need this reflection today. Send it to your family, your friends, your classmates, your colleagues or your group, and start a conversation worth having.

Instagram, TikTok, YouTube and Nextdoor do not accept a direct link share from a web page. Those buttons copy the message and link, then open the app site so you can paste it into a post, story, comment or message.

Sources & References
About the AuthorSpecialty Digest Editorial TeamEditorial StaffReporting and analysis from the Specialty Digest editorial team.
Share
Link copied